Well I personally liked this season. Although I feel like alot of the characters that went early had potential; Emilee in perticular. I think if Shaniqua or Jackie went farther than they did they would've got annoying. Penny and Jackie's eliminations were perfect. I however think that Xero making merge shouldn't have happened. Geena and Malik were also pretty irrelevant, I think something should've happened with them, maybe Geena betraying Iraenus. I dunno, something.
I still liked this season, but some character progression could be improved.
I kinda agree. This season hasn't been that impressive but I would still read it over SFCAS and SFC7. I think there are is one big problem; this season just feels like it was created soley as a TakeThat to RI. The OTTNN sassy chick that could have been entertaning was booted first, just like in RI, and the season has been less entertaing as a result, just like RI. Why the outcast twist? Because SWSU wanted to "do it right", unlike RI. Many people have been complaing that the editing is too balanced and MOR. Pretty much the exact oppisote of RI. The big personalites; like Shaniqua and Jackie, left early, kind of the oppisote of RI. Melaine is the "best player ever", unlike most of the people on RI. She also backstabbed the leader of her alliance, a.k.awhat Nat/Andera/Ashley SHOULD have done. There is no clear majority, unlike you guessed it, Redemtion Island. Matt is a Russell/Boston Rob parody, Johnny is a Nat parody, Heniz is a (RL) Matt parody, Malik is a Phillip parody, etc. I feel this season could'e been amazing if SWSU had wanted to create a good season, not simply a mocking of a bad survivor season that should be forgotten.
This was not meant to be offensive towards SWSU, and I apolgize for the giant paragraph. Had to say that, sorry.
The big personalites; like Shaniqua and Jackie, left early, kind of the oppisote of RI. wtf is this? Uh, Phillip and Rob were the only big personalities!!! at the merge. >_> SFC8 had Mutt, Melanie (i guess), Hannah, Heinz (i guess) and maybe more (lol).
Malik being Phil... Not even close. Malik was OTT2 at best while Phillip was forever OTTN88. Plus people actually cared about Phil while Malik... yeah.
Two more final things. If this is to Gejo... reply to Gejo with it. I had to tell Gejo on AIM so he'd see it. Secondly, don't bother writing all that and then apologizing or saying no offense! because it just sort of... kills it.
i have had ENOUGH. melanie you are a SEASON RUINER. i can't stand looking at you, reading your confessionals, thinking that you're gonna be featured in the next comic. i find you revolting. i'm so over these comics where someone goes up to melanie and the whole scene plays out like this: someone: ok so melanie do you think you can vote.. melanie: i already know whats going on. just tell me who you're voting someone: how did you know? O____O melanie: just say a name someone: k O_O damn you're good melanie conf: i control everyone.
SHE IS RUINING THE ENTIRE SEASON WITH THIS SHIT. if her partner oehda was a season SAVER, shes the complete opposite. i dont care if you want the best player ever swooso. this is embarassing. the whole situation is constructed so that melanie comes out victorious and shes doing nothing to earn this. do i really want someone like this in a fanfic? NO. you know how much i hate underdogs, but at least they give some spice to a season since they have to fight, and this is exactly what melanie is missing. sfc8 has basically been: how to create the best player ever. and im so over it. so over it
The problem I have with Melanie is scenes like this:
Melanie: Stay loyal to me or I will murder you after the show. (X): Even though there must be laws against making those kinds of threats, I am completely cowed and will do your bidding.
(X): I have no memory of the threat Melanie made against me. I will do whatever I want. Melanie: I have also somehow completely forgotten about that threat. Never mind, I will make it against someone else now.
sorry for what? making this season the most apathetic and waste of space ever? seriously how could you THINK that having geena in the f5 would be a good idea? that having everything go melanies way was exciting and a good idea? that heinz returning would effectively put a twist on things? SORRY ABOUT THIS? IT WAS A RETARDED DECISION AFTER ANOTHER, AND I CANT EVEN THINK OF THE PEOPLE YOU DECIDED TO ELIMINATE PREMERGE. who would ever have emilee, shaniqua and jackie all leave premerge while johnny, zero and geena are still in? theres something wrong with you. like forreal